Tile & Flooring

Regrout, Recaulk or Retile? Fixing Bathroom Tile

By [OWNER NAME]·January 26, 2026·Last updated January 26, 2026

Grout vs caulk — they're not the same

Grout fills the gaps between tiles; it's rigid and lives in the flat field of tile. Caulk seals the flexible joints — where the tub meets the wall, where the shower floor meets the wall, and in corners. They do different jobs, and mixing them up is a common cause of leaks.

Grout in a flexible joint cracks because the tub moves when it's filled. Caulk between tiles in the field fails because it isn't meant to be there.

Signs you need to recaulk

Recaulk when:

Recaulking means removing the old caulk fully, cleaning and drying the joint, and applying a fresh bead of silicone — not just laying new caulk over old.

  • The caulk around the tub, shower base, or corners is cracked, peeling, or mouldy.
  • You see a gap where the tub meets the wall.
  • There's water getting behind the tub or shower trim.

Signs you need to regrout

Regrout when:

Regrouting means raking out the old grout to a proper depth, cleaning the joints, and applying new grout — then sealing it once cured.

  • Grout lines are cracked, crumbling, or missing in places.
  • Grout is stained or mouldy and cleaning isn't bringing it back.
  • Tiles are solid but the joints look tired.

When it's time to retile

Retile when:

A retile is a bigger job: remove the old tile, repair the substrate, redo the waterproofing, set new tile, grout, and seal. It's the right call when a regrout or recaulk won't hold.

  • Tiles are loose or hollow-sounding — the bond to the substrate has failed.
  • The substrate (wall or floor behind) is water-damaged or spongy.
  • Many tiles are cracked, not just one or two.
  • The waterproofing has failed and water is leaking through.

Doing it right

The difference between a repair that lasts and one that fails in a year is almost always in the prep — fully removing the old material, drying the joint, and giving cure times the respect they deserve. Silicone needs 24 hours before water touches it; grout needs to cure before sealing.

For condos, check the bylaws before any tile or flooring work — they often regulate flooring and underlay.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between grout and caulk?

Grout fills the rigid gaps between tiles in the field. Caulk seals flexible joints — where the tub meets the wall, corners, and the shower base. They aren't interchangeable.

Should I regrout or recaulk my shower?

If the issue is cracked or mouldy caulk at the tub or corners, recaulk. If the grout lines between tiles are cracked or crumbling, regrout. If tiles are loose or the substrate is water-damaged, it's time to retile.

Can you just put new caulk over old?

No — it won't bond and it won't last. The old caulk has to come out fully, the joint cleaned and dried, then a fresh bead of silicone applied and given time to cure before water touches it.

When should I retile instead?

When tiles are loose or hollow, the substrate is water-damaged, many tiles are cracked, or the waterproofing has failed. A regrout or recaulk won't hold in those cases.

Need a hand with this? Get a free quote

Tell us what you need done — we'll get back to you with a clear quote.

CallGet a free quote